• Top 10 Deadly Lawsuits Against Churches - Clergy Confidentiality v. Mandatory Reporting of Suspected Child Abuse

    -

Fb Share

Several years ago an article was published in a magazine called “Christianity Today” which identified what the author believed to be “Ten Deadly Lawsuits”.  He subtitled the article: “Your church may be more vulnerable than you think”.  Here is the list of those ten lawsuits churches are exposed to (at least when this article was published in 2001; NOTE: these are not listed in any particular order):
1. Suits based on negligence—general public.
2. Suits based on negligence—parishioners.
3. Suits based on negligence—"nuisances" that attract children.
4. Suits based on negligence—supervision of employees.
5. Suits based on sexual harassment.
6. Suits based on defamation.
7. Suits based on apparent authority.
8. Suits based on disputes over election of the pastor.
9. Suits based on disclosure of confidential information.
10. Suits based on unfair acts.

I want to take a few moments and address the exposure listed as #9: “Suits based on disclosure of confidential information.” 

In 1974 the Child Abuse Prevention & Treatment Act (or CAPTA) was introduced, designed to protect children and to create mandatory reporting policies relative to suspected child abuse.  CAPTA was most recently revised and passed by Congress in January 2007.

CAPTA gave much momentum to what has become known as “Clergy as Mandatory Reporters of Child Abuse and Neglect”.  The dilemma is that through the years, clergy have felt the “protection” of what have always heard referred to as “Privileged Communication”; that is, the freedom and privilege of clergy to receive confidential information in the course of their counseling or standard ministry practice and know their rights to keep that information privileged between the parishioner and the clergy.  Many have heard of this protection under the terms of either “attorney-client privilege” or “doctor-patient privilege”, however, many states do in fact recognize “clergy-parishioner privilege.”  So then, what does a pastor do when he has information that under CAPTA might require that he report a potential child abuse situation, however, under clergy-parishioner protection he feels the need to protect the information he or she has received?

Basically all 50 states, the District of Columbia and the U.S. territories all have statutes that identify the persons who are required to report child maltreatment and/or abuse under certain circumstances.  The laws in each state differ in varying degrees.  In several of these states, clergy are included in those who are required by law to report such suspicions.  But then there are also laws which allow for what has become known as "Privileged Communications”. 

So, here is a scenario to consider.   A divorce couple has split custody over a child; we will call the child "Johnny."  One Sunday the pastor of the church where Johnny’s father attends notices some bruises on Johnny.  That particular weekend Johnny has been staying with his father.  During the invitation at the end of the service Johnny's father comes forward to tell the pastor that he needs prayer for his temper.  They pray together and the pastor asks to meet with Johnny's father after church.  They meet and Johnny's father admits that he shoved Johnny after getting upset with him and that is how Johnny got his bruises.  The father admits this has happened before but now he is through with his fits of rage.  The pastor provides counsel, but decides to take no action relative to advising Johnny’s mother or any authority.

Fast forward several weeks and the pastor gets a call from Johnny's mother.  She learns from Johnny what has happened and wants to know why the pastor did not tell her or report this to the authorities.  The pastor cites his "clergy-parishioner" privilege.  Two weeks later the pastor and the church are sued by Johnny’s mother.

Now let me through out some questions to consider.
1. As a pastor friend, church deacon/elder, or consultant, how would you direct the pastor in this situation back when he/she was made aware of the possible abuse?
2. How does Romans 13:1-3 regarding being subject to “higher powers” impact a pastor’s responsibility to keep confidence?
3. What language would you consider putting in a written “Child Safety Policy” relative to the pastor’s responsibility to report to authorities the possible child abuse?
4. How does the church respond to Johnny’s mother if she is a member?

Let’s all understand first that this is a scenario, but probably one that has much reality to it.  And I realize there are so many factors that can play a role here.  It is NOT my desire to stir up any issues relative to taking sides, but to present an exposure within a church and provide proper direction as to what pastor’s and churches need to do.  But probably more importantly the goal here is to get pastor’s and churches thinking ahead to various scenarios that could easily impact the livelihood and ministry of any church.  Let’s face it, child abuse is a very serious concern in our country.  And it is my belief that the BEST place for people to turn to for help is the local church.  But if someone needs help and they feel they can not go to anyone for fear of being reported, well then, what happens to that parent?  Or worse, what happens to that child.

Something to consider!

CLOSING COMMENTS:  This subject matter is becoming more and more sensitive.  I have provided below several links that you might want to visit to review some of the materials available relative to this subject.  But more importantly, if you yourself are part of a local church, you might want to provide some sort of direction or at minimum direct your senior pastor where he or she might want to go on-line to complete additional research for their protection.


Overview of Child Abuse Prevention & Treatment Act (CAPTA) http://www.childwelfare.gov/pubs/factsheets/about.cfm

Complete copy of CAPTA The complete text of the law (U.S. Code title 42, chapter 67) http://www4.law.cornell.edu/uscode/42/ch67.html

Copy of Child Welfare Information Gateway article with summary of state laws for each state.   http://www.childwelfare.gov/systemwide/laws_policies/statutes/clergymandatedall.pdf

National District Attorneys Association (NDAA)-association of prosecutors against such actions; 112 pages; very exhaustive state listing
http://www.ndaa.org/pdf/mandatory_reporting_state_statutes.pdf


Michael R. Boutot
 

  

Disclaimer. This post/blog/web page does not constitute legal advice. This is a rapidly changing area of the law. You should consult a lawyer if you have any questions about your reporting duties. On-line legal information can become out of date and are subject to legal interpretation depending on particular facts and circumstances.

Michael Boutot is the founder of the Institute for Church Safety & Risk Management, LLC (ICSARM), a church consulting group specializing in insurance evaluations, risk management assessments and litigation management. Michael can be reached at michael@churchriskmanagement.org or via phone at (662) 322-6713. To learn more about ICSARM, visit http://www.ChurchRiskManagement.org.

User Comments – Give us your opinion!
Leading from the Lion's Den
Videos
'I don't like my church,' says the pastor

Pastor Danny Chambers came home one Sunday and said, "I don't like my church. I wouldn't attend my church." His wife said, "You need to define what a winning church looks like to you."
 

 
A six-step strategy for disciple-making

Maturing the believers in your church is the ultimate goal of the Great Commission. (Aubrey Malphurs at a consultant training session hosted by the Society for Church Consulting)
 

 
Ten tactics from Proverbs to help you manage conflict

This rapid-fire list of concepts and verses will arm you with things to do when conflict takes root in your church. (Tom Harper at Church Central Turnaround 20/20)
 

 
Elmer Towns: The next big church turnaround method

"Life groups are changing today's church." (From Church Central's Turnaround 20/20 summit in 2012)
 

 
John Maxwell launches a prayer meeting

When he was a pastor in San Diego, Maxwell went against the wishes of his board and started a new prayer ministry that helped the church grow. Here's how he did it. (Elmer Towns at Church Central Turnaround 20/20)
 

 
Do some churches do more harm than good?

When a church doesn't make disciples, its value to the Kingdom is questionable. (Aubrey Malphurs leading a training session for the Society for Church Consulting.)
 

 
How weaknesses help leaders win spiritual battles
Chuck Lawless, Dan Reeves and John Ewart talk about the power of brokenness in fighting Satan in a church turnaround situation. We all have weaknesses that the enemy is very aware of, and when we direct our fear toward God rather than him, we …
 
Bandero Road Church's 7 'how we live together' statements

Will Mancini discusses how this church defines what a disciple should look like in their congregation. (From Church Central Turnaround 20/20)

 
» View More Videos